Cross-referencing Google Postmaster Tools with the data in your bulk mailing tools

Particularly if you‘re not sending the same high volume of mail every day — if you go days or weeks without sending a bulk mail at all, or send list-wide messages every few days and only send to smaller segments or test groups in between — you might want to cross-reference your complaint rates against the data you have in your bulk mailer.

Cross-referencing data: how much mail did I send?

Remember, it‘s just not known yet whether & how much Google will punish you for getting four spam complaints on a day when you sent ten emails to active Gmail users — a 40% complaint rate on very low volume.1 But you should definitely expect to be punished for lower rates on higher volume, like a 2% complaint rate (4,000 complaints) on a day when you sent 200,000 emails to active Gmail users!

So if you see a high spam rate in Google Postmaster Tools, it‘s worth checking what your mail volume actually looked like on and around that day.

Google won‘t tell you that. But of course, you can get that from your bulk mailing tools, just by pulling up the messages sent on a particular day and seeing how many recipients there were.

That number will probably be much larger than what Google is using, because it includes:

  • Recipients who aren‘t using Gmail at all
  • Inactive Gmail accounts
  • Members who never saw your mail at all because it went straight to spam
  • People who Google decides aren‘t actively engaging with your mail anyway and shouldn‘t count

But, in broad strokes, it‘s a helpful number to look at, both for the day that you see a high spam rate, and for the few days prior.

  • If you have a high spam rate on Tuesday but sent a very low volume of mail on Tuesday and the whole week prior: recipients are getting caught up on their email, so this is probably not indicative of a big problem.

  • If you have a high spam rate on Tuesday, sent a lot of mail on Sunday or Monday, but sent very little mail on Tuesday: recipients are getting caught up on their email, but this might mean your recent mails got a lot of complaints.

  • If you have a high spam rate on Tuesday and sent a lot of mail on Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday: you have a high spam rate on high volume, so you definitely need to address this!

Of course, the more consistent your email volume is from one day to the next, the less necessary it will be to cross-reference dates to look at volume.

Cross-referencing data: which mailings got the complaints?

If you do see signs of a problem with your bulk mail, you may want to get a sense of which specific mailings were generating the spam complaints.

Everything below here is just incoherent notes

Your spam rate as seen in Google Postmaster Tools will never really match up with the spam rates reported within your bulk mailing tools, because:

  • Your mailer is probably reporting unsubscribe/complaint rates per mailing, regardless of when the unsubscribe/complaint activity actually takes place. By contrast, remember that Google Postmaster Tools will be reporting those rates per day, regardless of when the mailing was actually received.
  • The complaint rates you see in your mailer will be across all mailbox providers that offer a traditional feedback loop — so you‘ll be able to see complaint rates for all the major providers except for Gmail.
  • Your mailer will also provide you with unsubscribe rates, and may let you subdivide those into ”people who clicked on a link in my email and unsubscribed on a landing page” versus ”people who unsubscribed from their inbox via the List-Unsubscribe mechanism.“ But that won‘t tell you which — or how many — Gmail users complained!

If you‘re able to pull records of recipients with @gmail.com addresses who unsubscribed using List-Unsubscribe mechanisms, and access the date of each of those unsubscribes, you can try to see over time whether that metric has any correlation with your complaint rate. (Is this even a useful thing to mention? I have no idea right now.)

Gmail get a count of break will also have Even then, you’ll actually never be seeing spam complaints from Gmail recipients in your mailer. At most you’ll be seeing “unsubscribed via inbox” activity from those recipients, which correlates somewhat with spam complaints (because spam complainers are generally also unsubscribing) but is an entirely different measurement that will include a lot of polite non-complaining unsubscribers. And Google doesn’t want you worrying directly about that polite-unsubscribers number as a poor deliverability indicator.


  1. Again, our common-sense guess is that they really won‘t care much about this, as long as you‘re getting low overall spam rates on your high volume mailings. But we may be wrong. ↩︎

© 2024 The Third Bear Solutions, LLC
About Contact